These homemade chocolate peanut butter eggs are easy to make, and they taste just like classic Reese’s peanut butter egg Easter candies!

Copycat Reese’s chocolate peanut butter eggs

Dear Easter Bunny,

I want just one thing for Easter: a basket filled sky high with these chocolatey, peanut buttery homemade chocolate peanut butter eggs.

Do you think you can do this for me?

I will be your best friend.

In return, I will make you a giant batch of Healthy Carrot Cake Cupcakes.

I will do your laundry for a month. You can keep the other candy.

Peeps shmeeps.

Homemade vs. store bought

The first great reason to make your own chocolate peanut butter eggs at home is to save money.

Just one package of Reese’s king size peanut butter eggs costs close to three dollars at the grocery store. In contrast, you can whip up an entire batch of DIY chocolate eggs for the same price.

And unlike the famous yellow packaged version, these homemade Reese’s peanut butter eggs include dairy free, nut free, vegan, gluten free, added sugar free, low carb, and oil free options, with no artificial flavors.

The best part is that the homemade chocolate eggs taste almost exactly like the ones you know and love from childhood!

It is so simple to make your own at home that you may never want to buy a package of chocolate peanut butter eggs again.

Craving peanut butter? Make Peanut Butter Cheesecake

Ingredients in chocolate peanut butter eggs

You need just four to five ingredients for these chocolate peanut butter Easter eggs.

Peanut butter – Choose your favorite smooth or crunchy peanut butter. Both natural and traditional jars work equally well.

For the best flavor, I recommend either going with a salted nut butter or stirring in about an eighth of a teaspoon of table salt.

Feel free to use a different nut or seed butter instead of peanut. Try almond butter, cashew butter, pistachio butter, Homemade Nutella, or allergy free sunflower butter.

Protein powder – Thicken and bind the candy eggs with your favorite flavored or unsweetened protein powder, oat flour, or almond flour.

Due to the difference in thickness among these three ingredients, you may need to either add more flour or more peanut butter to achieve the correct texture.

You may play around with other flours like spelt or coconut flour. However, I only stand behind the above options I have personally tried in my own kitchen.

Maple syrup – Pure maple syrup and honey or agave add sweetness to the Easter candies. I also include a keto version in the recipe box below, for those who prefer to use a powdered sweetener with no sugar added.

Chocolate – You have two options for the chocolate coating. The first option is to simply use melted dark or semi sweet chocolate chips. The second is to make a healthier chocolate sauce with cocoa powder, coconut oil, and maple syrup or stevia.

Chocolate peanut butter egg recipe video

Above – watch the step by step video.

How to make peanut butter eggs

If your peanut butter is not already soft and easy to stir, gently warm half a cup in the microwave or on the stove top to soften.

In a medium mixing bowl, stir together the softened peanut butter, protein powder or flour, and optional salt.

Mix in the pure maple syrup to form a crumbly dough.

Some nut butters and protein powders are drier than others, so you may need to add more peanut butter if the dough is too dry or more flour if it looks too wet.

Once the mixture achieves a peanut butter cookie dough texture, use your hands to shape oval eggs, rabbits, or other shapes of your choice.

Place the no bake chocolate eggs on a large plate lined with parchment paper or wax paper. Then refrigerate or freeze the plate while you prepare your chocolate sauce.

Chocolate covered peanut butter eggs

To make a chocolate coating using chocolate chips, carefully melt the chips in a microwave safe bowl or with the double boiler method. For a smoother sauce, stir in an optional teaspoon of coconut or vegetable oil after melting.

An alternative chocolate sauce: mix two tablespoons each of unsweetened cocoa powder, coconut oil, and pure maple syrup or honey (or two tablespoons water and stevia to taste) until completely smooth.

Take the peanut butter eggs from the refrigerator and cover them in melted chocolate with a spoon. Or dip each egg into the coating with a fork or a skewer.

Return the plate to the refrigerator or freezer for at least ten minutes. This step will set the chocolate shell.

I recommend refrigerating or freezing leftovers and enjoying them cold. However, you can leave the chocolate eggs out on the counter for a few hours in a cool place if serving at a party or for Easter dessert.

The best Easter candy

Chocolate peanut butter eggs have always been my favorite Easter treat. And it seems I am far from alone.

According to national sales numbers and polling data, Reese’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs are the most popular and highest selling Easter candy.

Year after year, chocolate peanut butter eggs beat out chocolate bunnies, marshmallow Peeps, Cadbury eggs, M&Ms, jelly beans, and Hershey’s Kisses.

Whether store bought or homemade, chocolate eggs are consistently number one in popularity for a good reason.

No one can resist these thick peanut butter candies with their smooth chocolate shell.

Serve a batch at your next Spring or Easter brunch, or keep them all for yourself!

*Pro Tip: This chocolate peanut butter egg recipe is great for other holidays too.

Use mini heart shaped cookie cutters to create chocolate peanut butter hearts for Valentine’s Day, chocolate pumpkins for Halloween, or festive Christmas trees and snowmen in December.

More About The Book

More Popular Easter Recipes

Carrot Cake Banana Bread

Easy Cinnamon Rolls

Carrot Cake Bars

Strawberry Pie

Vegan Sugar Cookies

Lemon Truffles

Greek Yogurt Cheesecake

Vegan Carrot Cake